CVIndependent

Sat10202018

Last updateTue, 18 Sep 2018 1pm

Many of my friends have stopped watching the news, checking their social-media feeds and listening to talk radio. They feel bombarded by claims and accusations and misstatements and alternative facts and post-truth political strategy.

Even people who have been active in the past are feeling disempowered and just hoping their lives don’t go too far south over the next four years. They hope we don’t get into a war. They wish the president and political parties would just get on with governing and let the process take its course. They’re tired.

However, Carlynne McDonnell isn’t tired at all. In fact, she’s expanding her activism—and organizing others to do the same.

Back in 2015, I wrote about McDonnell and her efforts to support and influence women with her book, The Every Woman’s Guide to Equality, containing advice on how women can stand up to situations in which they are treated with less respect than they deserve, in both the workplace and society in general.

After the presidential election, McDonnell decided to respond to what she saw as the “lack of people educated about how government works and (people) frustrated that they didn’t know what to do, or how to take a stand. Along with many other people, I was very disappointed after the election, and I don’t do well with sitting around. I’ve always been an activist. If I see a problem or situation, I need to find a solution.”

McDonnell began a Facebook group, Action for Societal Change, to provide information and organize others toward actions both public and private—from phone calls or emails to attending meetings or public demonstrations.

“People were feeling anxiety and despair,” she says. “They were having trouble knowing what’s real and what isn’t. Mostly, they wanted to know what they could do.”

McDonnell wanted to present information and offer suggestions on how to take action based on what she calls “vetted, proven, factual, mainstream news sources like (the Associated Press) and Reuters. I never post articles that have not been verified. Too much information is put out designed just to stir things up and provoke a desired response. I want to help people understand that everything posted—email, Twitter, news—isn’t always something that requires action. You have to be strategic. It’s a marathon, not a sprint.”

McDonnell, 57, a Palm Springs resident, came to the desert with her husband from Claremont almost five years ago. In addition to her writing and her activism, she’s in the process of fulfilling a personal soft spot by opening an animal sanctuary. Although she worked on a couple of political campaigns in the past, she says she would never run for office.

“I would never be able to keep from telling somebody to f--- off!” she says.

In a hyper-partisan and often vitriolic political climate, is there really anything individuals can do to make a difference through civic engagement?

“People need to slow down and take a breath. Understanding issues should be nonpartisan and regardless of religion, gender, or ethnicity,” says McDonnell. “I’m not a Pollyanna. I have no false illusions. But people have to realize the issues we’re facing are not going to go away, and we have to be able to trust the integrity of our information. We need an educated, measured approach to responding that doesn’t leave people feeling exhausted.”

McDonnell’s concept of how to feel empowered and make a difference is to put pragmatism over ideology.

“We all have to feel able to communicate: ‘That is not acceptable to me,’” McDonnell says. “Every day, our website posts at least one action individuals can take on their own. Whether you can give time, money, or just show up to learn and get involved, we welcome everyone regardless of political party.”

The group also has in-person meetings; the next one is scheduled for 2 p.m., Sunday, April 2, at the Unitarian Universalist Church of the Desert, 72425 Via Vail, in Rancho Mirage.

“There were so many people really hurting after the election, and some who are now regretting having supported the president,” she said. “I just wanted to find a way to bring people together. So far, we have about 450 local followers across the Coachella Valley. What we’re doing is not ‘hot and sexy’—it’s a methodical approach to being informed before you act. I want to appeal to those who have never marched or turned out to demonstrate and help them make their voices heard. I judge people on their willingness to do things for others, and this is about the willingness to make a commitment to bettering our country.”

Amid claims that professional organizers are orchestrating negative response to President Trump, Carlynne McDonnell stands as a refutation of that claim: She decided on her own to do whatever she can, and she is committed to helping others come together to do the same.

There are similar local organizing efforts throughout the country—individuals motivated only by their desire to make a difference. They are not paid protesters or political hacks. They’re people like Carlynne McDonnell, encouraging everyone to get beyond being tired of it all—and instead, to get up and make a difference.

Anita Rufus is also known as “The Lovable Liberal,” and her radio show airs Sundays at noon on KNews Radio 94.3 FM. Email her at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. Know Your Neighbors appears every other Wednesday.

Published in Know Your Neighbors

Every woman I know was thrilled by Carly Fiorina’s response at the second Republican debate to Donald Trump’s denigrating comment about her looks. Whether you agree with her policies or believe she is qualified to be president, her confident and direct hit at Trump was the standout moment.

“Look at that face!” Trump had proclaimed to a Rolling Stone reporter. “Who would vote for that?” When pushed to explain his denigrating comment, Trump claimed he was only talking about Fiorina’s “persona.”

During the debate, after Trump confronted Jeb Bush on his awkward comments about women’s health funding (which Bush claimed was a “mis-speak”), Fiorina was asked about Trump’s comments regarding her looks. With a calm, deliberate tone, she responded, “Mr. Trump said that he heard Mr. Bush very clearly and what Mr. Bush said. I think women all over this country heard very clearly what Mr. Trump said.” Bam!

Trump then followed with what every woman knows is the equivalent of a pat on the head: “She’s got a beautiful face, and she’s a beautiful woman.”

Sorry, Donald. Too little, too late.

Why were women so pleased with Fiorina’s response? Too few of us ever feel that confident to respond effectively to a man belittling us based on our looks. Having someone say, “You look nice today,” is always welcome. But when you’re in the boardroom, or the planning meeting, or a presidential debate, your looks are the last attribute you want noticed. It’s one of the small but persistent things that diminish women in public and private venues. When comments are made like, “That dress makes you look really sexy,” or, “Why would anyone vote for someone who looks like that?” it’s not only not OK; it should be socially unacceptable.

Statistics and analyses frequently illustrate the disparity between women and men in salaries and career opportunities, including the 85 percent dominance by men in Silicon Valley; the recently successful book, Lean In: Women, Work, and the Will to Lead, by Sheryl Sandberg; and disappointing numbers of women in creative leadership roles, such as those in movies and television (with a few notable exceptions like Tina Fey, the Amys—Schumer and Poehler, and Shonda Rhimes, used to refute the complaints: “Hey, they made it, so what are you complaining about?”).

All of this came to mind as I was reading Palm Springs resident Carlynne McDonnell’s book, The Every Woman’s Guide to Equality, which contains helpful advice for women on how to respond to situations in which they are treated with less than the full measure of respect they deserve.

McDonnell has been in the Coachella Valley for about three years. Her background includes a degree in humanities and a master’s in public policy. She has always been involved in writing, but professionally, it was usually of the technical variety, involving contracts, specifications, policies and procedures. Carlynne worked primarily in what she describes as “male-centric industries”—on the docks in Houston, and with the railroad in New Jersey. She felt compelled to write about the basics for women’s equality, particularly in the workplace.

“I felt I had not done enough to help other women,” she said. “Just listen to the way women are described, and the way women are talked about publicly. We’ve been desensitized to it, and it doesn’t seem like anyone stands up and says, ‘Stop it!’ It reaches the point where there is so much negativity, it can become overwhelming.”

Last year, McDonnell decided it was time to speak up and make a difference.

“I started the book last April, because I wanted to address how women can come together to have the greatest impact,” she says. “Women need to stop being so divided and talk in terms of our most-common factor: We are all women. Although we are not encouraged to speak our minds, we must do something instead of nothing. We can effect change as a group with the power of our voices and our dollars, but we need a continuous effort. We can and must change the world.”

For McDonnell, individual activism is a key component of the change she sees as necessary: “We need to demand a culture of success where the most qualified, regardless of gender or race or any other factor, is the one hired to do the job.”

She sees too much reliance on old ways of doing things, or people wanting to hire people just like themselves, or policies that don’t make a conscious effort to overcome old biases.

“I have a problem with the idea of ‘unconscious bias,’” she said. “On some level, it becomes conscious exclusion, and that’s what policies have to overcome. These things should not have to be legislated—they’re just good policies. But ultimately, the long-term message must be, ‘You can pay me now, or it will cost you a lot more later.’”

McDonnell also focuses on violence against women, as she sees a shifting view of responsibility: “People don’t realize how many women are killed every year. We call it ‘domestic’ violence, but the way we view women in crisis is often that the onus falls on the woman. Even women will say, ‘Why didn’t she just leave?’”

McDonnell’s book includes a chapter on health-care bias, where the emphasis is too often on diseases that get the most financial profile and support, such as breast cancer, compared to those that have higher death rates for women, like heart disease or stroke.

She also highlights the role of men and the need for them to have raised consciousness about the often subtle ways in which women are publicly disrespected. Her husband “has walked out of car dealer showrooms and declined to move forward with contractors who showed disrespect for me. He not only gets it; he acts on it.”

How can women learn to respond, like Fiorina, when their efforts are trivialized or disrespected? McDonnell includes many helpful suggestions that women can incorporate into their everyday lives. If you’re treated inappropriately at a store or restaurant, speak to someone in charge, and let them know why you will no longer spend your money in their establishment. Ask questions of your health-care providers about whether their recommended treatment is specific to women, or whether the testing and protocols were only researched with men. Stand up for women whose voices may not be heard. Get angry and vocal with police departments and elected officials who do not make safety, security and equality for women high priorities. Speak up when people use trivializing language about women and girls: “Don’t let ‘like a girl’ be anything more than an empowering battle cry to strive and succeed.”

McDonnell’s bottom-line message is that women must stand up and be heard, be role models, mentor others and educate without intimidating. “We allow our power to be diminished by not responding. Every time you stand up for yourself, you stand up for those who cannot do so. ”

Carly Fiorina gave us a good model of how to do that. Carlynne McDonnell is attempting to empower us all to do the same.

Anita Rufus is also known as “The Lovable Liberal,” and her radio show airs Sundays from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m. on KNews Radio 94.3 FM. Email her at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. Know Your Neighbors appears every other Wednesday.

Published in Know Your Neighbors